Top 5 Old Fashioned Popcorn Popper Reviews

People eat popcorn all around the world. Not only are they easy to cook, but this is a healthier snack compared to processed food. Furthermore, you can add butter and other ingredients for taste.

There is something about this food that makes it enjoyable. People eat them while watching their favorite movie, show, or even while reading a book. Some might like eating them during a car ride. The bottom line is that they are fun to eat. Kids and adults alike enjoy eating popcorn. So, of course, you might want some for yourself.

With the market filled with various poppers coming at different price points, it might be tough to make a decision. What sort of device do you search for? Are you interested in buying a small one for microwaves? Do you search for one to place over an open fire? Or go all out by buying old-fashioned poppers?

The answer to these popper questions comes down to personal preference. If you’re someone who likes serving a lot of popcorn, then we suggest buying old-fashioned poppers.

Now, don’t worry because old-fashioned poppers are still up for the task. They don’t allow you to make popcorn in a microwave but they do offer large serving sizes. Furthermore, they are durable, easy to handle, and clean.

We’re going to help with your buying decision process. To help you narrow down your search, we have chosen the best old-fashioned popcorn makers you should consider buying. Are you ready? Let’s get started!

Top 5 Old Fashioned Popcorn Poppers Comparison Table






Here’s Why Hot Air Popcorn Is Super Healthy

A small 3 cup serving of oil free popcorn contains:
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 14% percent of your daily recommended fiber intake
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 35 milligrams of magnesium
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 86 milligrams of phosphorus
Air popped popcorn is one of those rare snacks that tastes great yet still packs a powerful nutritional punch. Magnesium supports your immune system and phosphorus is good for your kidneys. Also, the fiber found in popcorn helps reduce food cravings, making it an ideal mid-day snack for dieters.

Top 5 Best Old Fashioned Popcorn Poppers

You might be surprised by the sheer number of old-fashioned popcorn makers within your price range. There is still a lot for you to choose from. That is why you need to make a choice that works best for you. If you search for the best deal and value, you need to sort through the thousands of options. This would take a lot of time.

Nobody wants to end up buying a product that doesn’t deliver. Also, buying a popper that takes too long is going to be a disappointment too. All of the old-fashioned models mentioned below are some of the top rated choices to go for.

The Numbers

  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Is able to make 5-quart of popcorn in three minutes.
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Measures 10 x 17 x 8 inches
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Item weight is 2 pounds

Best Suited For

Is it worth buying? Yes, it is particularly suitable for people who like to make a big batch of popcorn in one go.

This Great Northern Popper is a reliable product that is worth the price. It made from stainless steel. Also, it allows you to make 5-quart of popcorn in a couple of minutes. It doesn’t burn popcorn due to the unique spinner.

Furthermore, it has a wooden safety handle to avoid burns. This means you can use this popper without heat-pads. The vented lid can help to release moisture.

You can also clean it with a paper towel. The duplex head pad ensures that the popcorns are evenly heated.


  • It has a Wooden Safety handle and comes with a spinner stirring mechanism to prevent burns.
  • Easy cleanup - All you need to do is wipe the machine with a paper towel before storing it for later use.
  • Vented lid to release moisture.
  • Make 5-quart of popcorn in three minutes.
  • Even heating thanks to the high-quality Duplex heat pad.


  • This device doesn’t bear working on induction ranges, so it won't work with induction burners and heating systems either.
  • It might look a bit ugly to come users because of its old-fashioned design; however, it’s a matter of personal taste.
  • No free shipping - Unlike some brands that offer free shipping for their products, Great Northern doesn't provide this option.

The Numbers

  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Makes up to 24-cups of popcorn per batch
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Measures 21 x 16.5 x 53 inches
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Weighs around 45 pounds

Best Suited For

Commercial purposes or for serving huge parties at home.
The design of this old fashioned popcorn popper will take you back in time. It can produce up to 24-cups of popcorn per batch. Furthermore, it is easy to clean. The kettle is a stainless steel one and carries 6-ounces. This popcorn popper has a built-in stirring system. The lids are dual hinged. You’ll also get a kernel catcher to dispose of unpopped kernel. Serving is easy with the tilt door.


  • Pops up to 24-cups of popcorn per batch.
  • Easy to clean - It is important to point out that the kettle features a removable design for easy cleaning.
  • Kernel catcher included - Just like other Nostalgia models, it comes with a catch tray for kernels.
  • Easy serving access because of the tilt door that allows for effortless serving and scooping.
  • The product is removable for countertop use. Simply remove the top from the base if you have a problem with floor space.


  • Assembly may take some time - It might be a problem for some users, as there are a lot of parts to put together. To make matters worse, the instructions are not so clear.
  • The motor is not so durable - Even though the motor holds up well to wear and tear, the heating element is prone to failure after a while. It can't withstand years of heavy use.
  • Weak kettle mixer - According to some reviews, the kettle tends to get stuck when adding more than half of a pre-measured pack.

The Numbers

  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Makes 12-cups of popcorn per batch
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Measures 7.5 x 9 x 16.5 inches
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Weighs only 2 pounds
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Runs on 110V

Best Suited For

People interested in eating oil-free popcorn. It is recommended for serving large parties.

This is another Nostalgic old fashioned popcorn popper. It is able to serve twelve cups of popcorn in a batch. The unique chamber ensures almost all kernels are popped. Furthermore, the size is also convenient.

You also don’t need oil. So, the popper makes healthy popcorn. This is because it used hot air.


  • Healthy oil free snacking - Oil appears to get sort of a bad rap lately when it comes to food preparation. You will not have to worry about that as this unit utilizes hot air to make guilt-free snacks.
  • You get a measuring cup too - It will ensure that you always get the right amount of kernels
  • Unique popping chamber - This nifty feature reduces the number of unpopped kernels by creating swirling airflow.
  • Makes 12 cups at a time in one batch.
  • Great value for the price.


  • Load operation - While the unit can be a bit loud for some users, most of them get used to it quickly.
  • Air pressure could be better - The air pressure is not capable of pushing all the contents out, which is why you will have to tip it yourself every now and then.

The Numbers

  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 1.5 gallons of popcorn in a single batch
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Comes in at 17.3 x 23.6 x 20 inches
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 The product weighs 31.2 pounds
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Operates at 600 Watts

Best Suited For

Excellent for people with a home theater setup and who like to invite a lot of friends over. Enjoy as much popcorn as you want during a group viewing party.

This popper is another good choice. It enables you to cook a big batch of popcorn in less time. You can easily make 1.5 gallons of popcorn in about five minutes. This will help you save time and money.

So, what will you get? It also includes steel accessories. You’ll get a salt shaker, a measuring cup, and a spoon. You’ll also get a scoop and a detachable kettle. This item has two switches. One is for turning on the machine and the other for warming it. It also features safety tempered glass side panels.


  • Features safety tempered glass side panels - This useful feature is meant to prevent burns and make the unit safe to use.
  • It comes with accessories that make things a whole lot easier.
  • Easy to use - Most customers find it quite simple to use and clean.
  • Pretty fast - You will be able to prepare your favorite snack in no time.


  • No color options to choose from - Keep in mind that this product is only available in red.
  • Size might be too bulky for some users - This can be a problem for those who don't have a lot of space in their kitchen.

The Numbers

  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Makes produces 147 one-ounce servings per hour
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 3-year warranty
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 Measurements come in at 22 x 18 x 29 inches
  • Popcorn-popper-hub-logo2 The product in question weighs 61.9 pounds

Best Suited For

People who want to serve large batches of popcorn at home. Those who want to start their own food selling business should also consider buying it.

You can experience a real theater-like feeling with an old-fashioned popcorn machine. It is able to provide 147 one-ounce servings in a home. This makes it perfect for feeding a large home party or even for setting up a selling shop. The choice is yours.

It is easy to operate. It also features an anodized aluminum kettle which is easy to clean. This antique-designed machine also has tempered glass panels. The heating deck heats your batch uniformly. Finally, you will also get an old-maid drawer. It sifts through and catches kernels (that haven’t popped) for later disposal.


  • Tempered glass for safety and hygienic reasons.
  • Produces 147 one-ounce servings in an hour.
  • You will get an old-maid drawer for sifting through disposable kernels.
  • Fair price.


  • Operating it might be tough for some users.

Final Thoughts on the 5 Best Top Rated Old Fashioned Popcorn Poppers

We know it is important for you to make popcorn whenever you want. These best old fashioned popcorn makers are surely up for the job. Select any old-fashioned model mentioned above and you’re sure to enjoy what it can make for you. Make sure you get your money’s worth. Looking for a cheap popcorn machine? Do you search the Internet for the best deal? Visit our home page for more honest reviews to get the best deals on the market. Remember that you will not get better value for your money elsewhere.